10 Most Popular Pizza Toppings in the U.S. (Full List + Ideas)

Ever wondered what is the most popular pizza topping? You're not alone! Americans are serious about their pizza and some toppings consistently rise to the top of the popularity charts. In a recent poll we find that Americans eat approximately 156 slices a year and eat pizza about once a week. Our love for pizza runs so deep that 75% of Americans would willingly give up social media for an entire month if it meant scoring free pizza for a year. 

Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, knowing pizza topping favorites can help you when you order pizza tonight. Let's look at the best pizza toppings and see if you agree.

What Are the Most Popular Toppings to Order on Pizza?

Pizza toppings aren't created equal in the hearts (and stomachs) of Americans. Some rise to legendary status while others remain niche favorites. The most popular pizza toppings earn their crown through the perfect balance of flavor, texture, and how well they complement the combination of cheese, sauce, and crust.

At Hungry Howie's, we see these top 10 pizza toppings ordered every day. Here’s the list of the most ordered pizza toppings in the United States. 

Pepperoni

There's absolutely no surprise here. Pepperoni reigns supreme as the most popular pizza topping in America. At Hungry Howie's, we don't mess around with our pepperoni, using only premium cuts that crisp up perfectly in our ovens, creating those beloved little cups that hold delicious pools of flavor. For serious pepperoni enthusiasts, our Pepperoni Duo Pizza doubles down on America's favorite topping for an experience that's twice as nice.

Extra Cheese

There's a reason "extra cheese" has become standard when ordering pizza. This pizza topping (can we even call it a topping when it's more of an enhancement?) transforms any pizza into a masterpiece. Our 100% mozzarella creates those Instagram-worthy cheese pulls and is definitely one of the favorite pizza toppings.

Mushrooms

Mushrooms bring an earthy punch that makes them popular with vegetarians and meat-lovers. These fun little fungi add a texture and flavor that can complement every other topping on pizza. Whether starring in a veggie medley or providing counterpoint to pepperoni and sausage, mushrooms have earned their spot among the pizza toppings list, as showcased on our Works Pizza.

Onions

The humble onion might seem like a background player, but don't be fooled, this veggie (also known as a fruit) brings sweet and savory to every slice. They're the unsung heroes of our BBQ Chicken Pizza, where they provide the balance to our tangy sauce and smoky chicken.

Sausage

Bold and meaty, sausage could easily claim to be one of the most popular pizza toppings if pepperoni ever decided to take a day off. Sausage is a staple for meat lovers everywhere. Experience sausage in its full glory on our aptly named Meat Eaters Pizza, where it's in excellent company with other meaty meats.

Black Olives

Black olives are perhaps the most polarizing member of the top toppings club, next to pineapple. You either love them or you leave them. These briny bombs lend a distinctive Mediterranean touch to pizza and provide that salty contrast that olive lovers find irresistible. They're stars of our Veggie Pizza, where these popular pizza toppings create harmony with other plant-based favorites.

Green Peppers

Crisp, colorful, and with just the right amount of sweet and sharp tang, green peppers bring texture and color to pizza. These popular pizza toppings maintain their crunch even after baking, providing a fresh bite when mixed with other pizza toppings. See them shine on our Howie Special Pizza on your next pizza delivery. 

Pineapple

And, here we go. The elephant in the room: pineapple on pizza divides the nation like no other topping. This sweet, tangy fruit creates passionate debate wherever it goes, but for all the naysayers, its persistent popularity suggests that the pro-pineapple crowd might be onto something. For those adventurous souls seeking unique pizza topping ideas, our Howie Maui Pizza showcases this controversial star with ham for a sweet-savory combo.

Spinach

Spinach might not be the first topping that comes to mind or even the third, but this green goddess has earned its place among the best pizza toppings. Wilted just enough in our hot ovens, spinach adds a taste that works best with creamy white sauces but can also stand up to stronger flavors. Try some spinach on your next pizza takeout. 

Plain Cheese

Like a clean white T-shirt, vanilla ice cream, or cup of black coffee, perfection lies in simplicity. Plain cheese pizza isn't just for picky kids, it's for purists who understand that perfectly melted cheese on quality crust with signature sauce is an experience that needs no embellishment. To be honest, cheese pizza is the foundation against which all other pizzas are measured.

Popular Pizza Topping Combos You Can Order at Hungry Howie's

While knowing the most popular pizza toppings is helpful, the real magic happens when these pizza toppings come together in unique combinations. The best pizza toppings lists might rank individual ingredients, but at Hungry Howie's, we've mastered the art of taking pizza topping ideas and making them into incredible pizza combinations.

Our specialty pizzas have earned loyal followings, including:

The Buffalo Chicken Pizza brings the heat with spicy buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and a cool ranch drizzle that creates a game-day favorite that outshines even the hottest wing platters.

For those who believe more is more, our 3 Cheeser Pepperoni Pleaser Pizza combines America's favorite topping with a trio of cheeses for an experience that takes indulgence to new heights.

The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza proves that some flavors were simply meant to be together. Chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch create a combination that has become a modern classic.

These signature combinations show how the pizza topping ideas can really work together! 

Order Pizza Online from Hungry Howie's for Delivery or Takeout

Ready to experience these spectacular pizza toppings for yourself? Ordering pizza online from Hungry Howie's couldn't be easier. Whether you're craving our specialty pizzas featuring the most popular pizza toppings or want to explore our Secret Menu for even more delectable pizzas, we have the pizza for you.

Feeling a little creative? Our build your own pizza option lets you craft your perfect pie from our pizza toppings list. Choose from classic favorites or experiment with new combinations!

No matter if you prefer pizza delivery straight to your doorstep or quick pizza takeout on your way home, finding the best pizza toppings is just a few clicks away. Check out our locations to find the Hungry Howie's nearest you, and get ready to enjoy your favorite toppings on your terms.

After all, life's too short for boring pizza!