Pizza Topping Ideas: The Best Pizza Toppings We Can't Resist!

HH_Pep_Duo

Did you know Americans devour around 350 slices of pizza every single second, or about an acre’s worth of pizza every day?! 

This is proof that there is a lot of decision-making going on about what to put on pizza, and we're here with some fresh ideas for pizza toppings and timeless classics that might inspire your next pizza night.

Most Popular Pizza Toppings: The Hall of Fame 

We’ll start with the GOAT of pizza toppings – PEPPERONI. This spicy, crispy champion isn't just the most common pizza topping in America; it's basically pizza royalty.  But it first appeared in Italian-American markets around 1919. Pepperoni as a pizza topping probably began around the 1940s or 50s and is truly an American invention. That’s right. Pepperoni pizza is not an authentic Italian pizza but was created right here in the United States. Ask for a pepperoni pizza in Italy and you might come away with something very different. 

We think the best pepperoni is the cupped version that curls when baked to hold all those delicious flavors. Of course, there is more than just pepperoni pizza. Additional pizza toppings we think are delicious include: 

  • Italian sausage 
  • Extra cheese (because there's no such thing as too much cheese)
  • Mushrooms 
  • Feta Cheese
  • Onions 
  • Green peppers (for the extra crunch factor)
  • Black olives
  • Hot honey drizzle
  • Bacon
  • Extra mozzarella (because we said MORE CHEESE)

We’ll return to our love of pepperoni, but we also have ideas for veggie pizza toppings and some very bold suggestions on what to put on pizza the next time you order. 

Best Pizza Topping Combinations

Pizza lovers already know the best toppings for a pie, and we get it; it’s hard to beat a classic. But we are going to tempt you with a few pizza combinations that might change your next pizza order. 

The Meat Eaters Dream

The Meat Eaters pizza has pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, AND ground beef swirled together with a generous helping of mozzarella cheese. It’s for people who love meat and have a big appetite. Order as is or add bacon and steak to take this meat pie over the edge. 

The Works

Order the Works when you can't decide on pizza toppings: Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, ground beef, mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra mozzarella cheese. It’s a little bit of meat and a little bit of veggies for the best of both! 

Pepperoni Duo Pizza

There’s pepperoni, and then there’s Pepperoni Duo. Sometimes the simplest pizza topping ideas are the best – and our Pepperoni Duo is basically pepperoni perfection squared! It has classic cupped pepperoni and the original for that extra, big bold pepperoni taste.  

Veggie Pizza Toppings That'll Make You Forget About Meat

Yes, you need to eat more vegetables and what better way to get them than in a delicious Veggie pizza. Our mix of veggie pizza toppings is so outrageously good we think it will turn you into a veggie lover. 

  • Mushrooms 
  • Bell peppers 
  • Red onions 
  • Black olives 
  • Red tomatoes

For an extra fresh taste, try green olives. Or add jalapeños - for when you're feeling spicy or banana peppers for a bit of tang.

How to Order Like a Pizza Pro: Secret Menu Hacks! 

Want to know what to put on pizza like a true pizza enthusiast? We've got some insider pizza topping ideas that'll change your ordering game.

The Double Down of Toppings

Listen, if you love a topping, GET MORE OF IT. Double pepperoni? YES. Double mushrooms? ABSOLUTELY. Double cheese? No problem! We’re here to make the pizza of your dreams. 

The Heat Seeker

Pro tip: Jalapeños and pepperoni are a match made in heaven. Order the Bee Sting off our Secret Menu or add them to any combination. Add some red onions to that mix, and you've basically created a masterpiece. Just don't forget to grab a drink because this pizza needs some liquid refreshments.  

Staff Expert Picks

Our pizza makers have some serious opinions about the best pizza toppings. Their current obsessions are grilled steak, banana peppers, and extra cheese. Don't knock it until you try it! And while we're here, let’s talk about some of those pizza toppings that don’t get a lot of love. Yes, pineapple and anchovies. Together, it’s a bold choice for pizza toppings and we’ll admit, is not the average pizza order. Individually, pineapple or anchovies can add a bit of spice and zest to any combination of pizza. Are you ready to give it a try? Start your order here!

If anchovies and pineapple are not included in your next order, we understand. There are plenty of pizza topping ideas to try, from classic pepperoni to whatever your imagination can come up with. So, the next time you’re not sure what to put on pizza, check out our pizza menu and toppings for ideas. Order your classic tried-n-true or go for the gold with a new combination. Hungry Howie’s is here to help you make the pizza of your dreams.